In case you don’t know this about me already, I might as well tell you. If there is one thing I love a whole lot in this world it is Harry Potter. Yes, I am a “Harry Potter” fangirl (and I use quotation marks because I am referring to the Harry Potter franchise. The actual character of Harry Potter- ew. I’m a Ron or Draco Malfoy girl myself.) I wouldn’t say that I love Harry Potter as much as William Shakespeare, but it is pretty up there. I mean, they are both from the same country so that has to count for something. Right then, off to the actual post. (Also, it is much better if you read this in a British accent. It helps you get into the correct setting.)
In just a few short days the latest Harry Potter movie will be coming out (the sixth in the seven volume series -book wise- and eight volume series- movie wise). Needless to say, I am VERY, VERY, VERY much anticipating this. As I am attempting to read fifty books throughout this year I have started to reread the HP series which led me to compare the movie to the book the ENTIRE time I was reading it. That led me to this little Bullshish series where I compare the movie to the book and validate the point that reading the book is ALWAYS better than seeing the movie. Let us begin. [Obvious warning- spoilers will jump out at various moments.]
Harry Potter and the Sorcerer’s Stone: The Book

Let us discuss the plot (in my own words) as it has probably been a while since anyone has read the book (unless you have never read it at all *cough*CALEB*cough*). Harry Potter is a normal boy who lives with the most horrible people on the earth. On the days leading up to his eleventh birthday he receives strange letters by a bunch of owls but his mean old uncle takes them away before he can read them. A giant shows up the exact moment Harry turns eleven and informs Harry that he is, in fact, not normal, but surprise! He is a wizard just like his parents were. The letter eventually gets to Harry (not even the Dursleys dare to mess with a giant) and Harry is whisked off to Hogwarts School for Witchcraft and Wizardry where he learns that he is extremely famous because when he was a baby he defeated the evil dark lord “he-who-must-not-be-named” (aka Voldemort for those, like our boy Harry, who aren’t afraid to speak his name) which also happens to be the reason his parents died. He makes friends and fights bad guys.
Let’s just cut to the chase- this isn’t my favorite book of the bunch. As the first of the series JK Rowling is finding her groove, a perfectly acceptable thing for all writers to do. I just don’t happen to like this book (mainly the first part) because if there is one thing I hate most in books and academic papers, it is choppy sentences. Yes, I do realize I write choppy sentences whilst blogging, but this isn’t being published! Millions and millions and MILLIONS of people are not flocking to my blog daily, hanging onto my every word, waiting with bated breath of just what I will say next! However, since this is the first book and things improve drastically as the series goes on, I can live with it. Rowling’s writing style is great. There aren’t any parts that I can recall where I felt as though this book was targeted towards a specific age group. I would have enjoyed this as a younger kid (I believe it came out when I was in fifth grade or somewhere around there but I didn’t start reading it until book five or six came out) and I will continue to enjoy it when I am ninety seven years old (provided I live that long). It is a very easy read, so easy in fact that as the fifth (or sixth) was slated to be released at midnight on my birthday I read the first four (or five) books in less than a month. And if you know anything about these books, they only increase with time.
The story is pretty well set up from the beginning. You can definitely tell that Rowling had the story planned out before she even pressed a letter on her keyboard. The first book sets up many important things you don’t even really find out until books five, six, and seven! The story wrapped up nicely and while still leaving you wanting more, it doesn’t leave you feeling as though you HAVE to pick up the next book RIGHT AWAY which is nice.
Harry Potter and the Sorcerer’s Stone: The Movie

So you want to make a movie adaptation of a book. To me, and this is strictly my opinion as I know nothing about adapting movies, much less writing screenplays (besides what I learned from Adaptation, which is kind of EXACTLY what we are talking about), but it seems as though this is a very difficult thing to do. What do you leave in and take out? What do you change to make the overall movie more appealing to audiences? Who do you cast that sort of resembles any idea of what the audience has created in their head while reading this book?
These are all very difficult questions to answer, especially with a series that hasn’t been completely published. If you omit something from book one is it going to magically show up as a major plot development in book five? How do you know? The answer- you don’t. What do you do? The answer- guess. I think as far as adaptations go, this was pretty decent. Compared to the adaptation of The Princess Diaries this movie is viewed as a masterpiece! (Don’t get me started on The Princess Diaries adaptations. That is another post for another time.) I think they kept in what they thought necessary, though a few bits here and there that I really loved were omitted. Nothing too significant (that I can remember at this moment in time) to the plot but just nice moments I liked.
As far as the characters go, I would say they did a great job. Whenever I start reading a book I always come up with how I think a character should look or sound, so when adaptations come out and there is finally a face and voice to the character and it is different than the one in my head, it can be difficult for me to accept. (For example, Twilight. Rob Pattinson is NOT Edward, NOT EVEN CLOSE. Kristen Stewert is NOT Bella, NOT EVEN CLOSE.) The Dursleys are one of the worst families I’ve ever encountered in a book. Uncle Vernon is just purely disgusting and all I want to do is reach out and punch Dudley. Aunt Petunia is also awful in the way she talks about her sister and treats Harry. They really did a fantastic job casting these guys. I don’t think they could have picked better people if they tried. As far as Harry goes, I like him well enough. I mean, he is the main character… I definitely would not say he is my favorite though. Casting wise, Daniel Radcliffe is perfect for the part because I happen to think he looks like the Harry Potter on the book covers. So well done there.
As for the rest of the cast- Rupert Grint was a lovely choice, as he has the Ron act down (you know… the pretending to be brave when really scared sh*tless act). Hermione is one I have mixed feelings about. Now, don’t get me wrong, Emma Watson is a beautiful, beautiful actress and really plays the part well. But this is Hollywood and Hollywood relies on sex appeal. In the books Hermione is described as being frumpy, ugly, basically far from beautiful. She has huge teeth and giant frizzy hair. In the movies, Hermione does not. I know that when casting a girl at such a young age it is sometimes difficult to predict what she will look like when she grows older, but they could still do things like frizzing out her hair (which I will admit they did in the first two films). This is when I don’t like film adaptations. Also, the characters of Fred and George. They have a MUCH larger part in the books, and while reading the books I really fell in love with their characters. They are so funny and have great jokes and laughs and moments. They are all but cut out of the films, especially the first. I want my proper dose of Fred and George!! The rest of the cast is great. McGonagall, Snape, Dumbledor, Nevil, Hagrid, etc. They are all fantastic actors who do the characters justice.
Harry Potter and the Sourcer’s Stone: The Moment of Truth
I would have to say (and expect this every time) that the BOOK wins the match. As with all books you are able to get more information, more scenes, more conversations and better insight into the character’s minds. Yes the movie is good, but I can not stress to you how much better the book is. If you enjoy reading and are looking to get into a series, do me a favor and put down the Twilight and pick up the Harry Potter. You will so thank me for this some day.