Just a little note: I might mention a few “spoilers” about Grey’s Anatomy in this post, but honestly, if you haven’t been watching it for the past five years and managed to hear NOTHING about it, I don’t think you are really going to care. But consider yourself warned anyway.

I used to consider myself a Grey’s Anatomy super-fan. I watched from the first ever episode. I watched it while out of town, on a television that was only half working (I could hear the voices but see nothing). I talked plot ideas with friends at school and had theories and all of that silly stuff. I was the BIGGEST Meredith/Derek fan out there. And then, one not so sunny day at Seattle Grace, a little character named Addison Montgomery Shepherd walked into our lives and it was never the same.
Okay, if you know nothing about the show then that probably didn’t make much sense. The show takes place in Seattle at a hospital called Seattle Grace (clever, no?). Meredith and Derek are this shows version of Ross and Rachel, except they tend to stay together more than R&R ever did. Somewhere during the first season Derek’s WIFE shows up (cue Addison) and things get out of hand. Now what this means to a MerDer shipper is that Addison is the DEVIL. She moves to Seattle, gets a job at the hospital (she is great friends with the Chief and just so happens to be the best neo-natal surgeon on the West coast, HOW CONVENIENT) and takes Derek back. Turns out she cheated on him with his best friend, causing him to move across the country and find himself a gal. Things like this continue on for a good two and a half seasons.
But something happened over those two and a half seasons. The writers got CRAZY and Addison became my favorite cast member. And when I say the writers got crazy, I don’t mean they did things that I didn’t like so I am calling them crazy as some sort of insult. I mean, THEY GOT CRAZY. Doctors dating terminally ill patients, doctors cutting LVADs so that terminaly ill patient can either get a new heart or DIE, terminally ill patient dying even though he got a new heart, doctors becoming psychotic, doctors sleeping with other doctors who are sleeping with other doctors, doctors sleeping with doctors who are MARRIED to other doctors, patients with BOMBS inside their stomachs causing a part of the hospital to blow up, and so on. After the third season I had to quit watching. Things got too insane too fast and it really lacked the charm from the first season.
Now, sometimes in the television world writers creat spin-offs. Sometimes they work, (all those CSI’s and Law & Order’s) and sometimes they don’t (did anyone even watch Joey?). Luckily Shonda Rhimes took a chance, made a spin-off, worked her magic and made it work. Not only did I stop watching Grey’s because it got too insane, but also because Addison was leaving. I did not want this to happen, as I previously said Addison became my favorite character. Her leaving made me very sad. But wait! All hope was not lost! For Addison was leaving Seattle Grace to go work in LA at Ocean Side Wellness Center, resulting in the amazing spin-off Private Practice.
The major difference between the two shows is that Grey’s takes place in a hospital, while PP is exactly what the name implies- a private practice. The practice consists of Dr. Naomi Bennett (played by Audra McDonald) who is a board-certified reproductive endocrinologist and fertility specialist. Basically she helps couples who are having trouble getting pregnant. Then there is Dr. Sam Bennett (Taye Diggs) who is a normal doctor (no specific field of study). He is also Naomi’s ex-husband and together they created the practice. Then there is Dr. Violet Turner (Amy Brenneman) the psychologist, Dr. Cooper Freedman (Paul Adelstein) pediatrician, Dr. Pete Wilder (Tim Daly) who deals with holistic healing, Dell Parker (Chris Lowell) who serves as the receptionist but is also a male nurse training to get his “midwifery” degree, and of course Addison Montgomery (Kate Walsh). Lastly there is Dr. Charlotte King (KaDee Strickland) who is actually not part of the practice. She is the Cheif of Staff at St. Ambrose Hospital which is where the practice goes if they need to do surgeries and stuff.
While similar to Grey’s in the fact that they deal with strange medical cases, Private Practice is a much calmer show. Shonda contines to write for both Grey’s and PP and while that might make you think they are very similar shows, I am here to tell you they are not. The first season of PP is only nine episodes long (one shorter than the first season of Grey’s) and they use every minute to draw you in and set up the characters. While it is an hour long show (or rather 41 minutes of actual dialogue) nine episodes is a very short amount of time to set up characters that you like and create enough interesting and relevent material to draw you back in for another season. Somehow it all worked out. The first season finale was dramatic enough, but it didn’t have the pull that made you sit back in your chair and say “what the heck just happened.” The second season was a full season (22 episdoes) and really invested time in the characters resulting in situations from the Shonda I knew before. Here and there I thought “this is something that would totally happen on Grey’s” which didn’t really bother me because it wasn’t enough to make me feel as though I was watching Grey’s on a weekly basis. However the second season finale had me screaming at the TV, crying, and thinking “Shonda has done it again.”
Very rarely do I scream at the television. If I do, I am either watching a very scary movie (which I try and make it a point never to do) or I am really invested in the show I am watching. I think I yelled something at the characters on probably 18 of the 22 episodes? Something like that. It is really hard NOT to get into this show. The situations seem more real than those on Grey’s resulting in me feeling as though I know these people and am part of thier lives (don’t mock; I have friends who feel this way too). The actors are all amazing, and the chemestry is fantastic. You can really tell that these actors love what they are doing, whereas (to me) all the drama behind the scenes of Grey’s made its way onscreen.
To sum up a long, detalied post (to which if you have made it all the way through I congratulate you) I think your time is better invested in Private Practice. If by some miracle this post has opened your heart to the genius that is Shonda Rhimes, I think you can easily get into PP. You can start the first season without having to have ever watched Grey’s Anatomy (though I do suggest you at least read wiki or something so you can know the whole Addison/Derek thing, which doesn’t play a huge part in the PP storylines but it still important to know). The actors are great, the characters are all likeable in their own way, the story lines are great without getting too insane, and the soundtrack is fantastic. Now hurry and get caught up! The new season starts October 1 at 10pm on ABC.




VS 

